Files
marqdo-cli/docs/STATUS.md
T
cflmy 0116160399 docs: formal specs, ADRs, STATUS matrix, contributor guide and honest README
Complete the documentation set for the M0.5 toolchain, grounded in the code:

- spec/references.md: import/reference/call edges, identities, loader rules,
  anchors, `ref` resolution/ambiguity, `check --refs` validation.
- spec/value-wire.md: exact wire_version 1 typed encoding, integer-as-decimal
  string rule, special floats, limits and exact float round-trip.
- spec/security.md: modes (strict refuses without OS isolation), capabilities,
  path rules, budgets, tracing, foreign process caveats, plugin trust.
- spec/package-format.md: marqdo.yaml/lock formats, validation, lock/sync,
  unsupported registry/git/environment work.
- spec/plugin-abi.md: ABI v1 layout/ownership/negotiation, manifest/artifact
  rules, wire envelopes, loader lifecycle, trust boundary, SDK/C demo, and the
  implemented CLI plugin-invocation flow with its limitations.
- spec/math.md and spec/foreign.md: the implemented math subset and the
  foreign request/response/timeout/capability contract.
- docs/adr/0001..0007: accepted decisions for the span foundation, inert
  executables outside function bodies, ref ambiguity (S-07), strict refusal,
  AST normalization, CLI contract and BigInt/typed wire (S-08).
- docs/contributor-guide.md: repo map, workflow, fixture/golden updates,
  quality gate, ADR/commit policy.
- docs/STATUS.md: P0-P7 matrix with evidence, open items and the blueprint §18
  Alpha checklist (conclusion: not yet Alpha-complete), including known
  divergences rather than overclaims.
- README.md rewritten from "design-only starter" to the working implementation
  with quickstart, implemented phases, deliberate limits and doc index.
- AGENTS.md: updated pointers/workflow only; architectural rules unchanged.
- Consistency fixes in spec/mapping.md/evaluation.md (inert emph outside
  functions, unsupported math.simplify/differentiate).
2026-11-20 10:56:26 +08:00

218 lines
16 KiB
Markdown

# Marqdo Implementation Status (M0.5)
Snapshot: **2026-11-20**, workspace version `0.1.0`, plugin ABI `1.0`,
`wire_version` 1, Markdown profile `marqdo.md.v1`.
This file maps the blueprint's phases (`docs/DEVELOPMENT_BLUEPRINT.md` §13) to
concrete evidence in the repository and lists honest open items. It is a status
report, not a promise. "Done" means implemented **for the documented subset**
and covered by tests; it does not mean the blueprint's full ambition is
complete.
Reproduce the evidence:
```bash
export PATH=/root/.cargo/bin:$PATH
export CARGO_HOME=/root/work/marqdo-cli/.cache/cargo
export CARGO_TARGET_DIR=/root/work/marqdo-cli/.cache/target
cargo test --workspace
cargo test -p marqdo-cli
cargo fmt --check
cargo clippy --workspace --all-targets -- -D warnings
```
## 1. Phase matrix
| Phase | Status | Main evidence |
|---|---|---|
| **P0** Formal specs + parser goldens | **Done** | `spec/markdown-profile.md`, `spec/mapping.md`, `spec/expression.ebnf`, `spec/evaluation.md`; frozen profile test `crates/marqdo-markdown/src/profile.rs`; 150 AST fixtures + goldens in `tests/conformance/ast/`; 48 compile-error fixtures in `tests/negative/`; `inspect --ast`; `conformance_ast.rs`/`negative.rs` harnesses. |
| **P1** Interpreter, expressions, control flow | **Done** | `marqdo-expression`, `marqdo-ir`, `marqdo-frontend`, `marqdo-runtime`; factorial/countdown examples run without Python (`examples/factorial.mq.md`, `examples/hello.mq.md`); 36 execution goldens in `tests/conformance/semantics/`; runtime tests `crates/marqdo-runtime/tests/interpreter.rs`; prose invariance `crates/cli/tests/properties.rs`. |
| **P2** Modules, references, CLI experience | **Partial** | Imports/ModuleId/UnitId/anchor/cycle detection + `run/call/check/inspect/fmt` (`crates/cli`), multi-module example and `multi_module_imports_and_cycles` CLI test; `check --refs` reference validation (all loaded documents, on-demand static analysis of link targets) and `inspect --refs` static graph. Missing: cross-module link calls, rename/interface-lock tooling, canonical AST-preserving `fmt` (see §3). |
| **P3** Package environment | **Partial** | `marqdo.yaml`/`marqdo.lock` types+validation (`marqdo-package`), `init`, `add`/`remove` (manifest editing), deterministic `lock`, `sync --locked`; CLI test `lock_and_sync_locked_detect_dependency_tampering`; `examples/multi-module`. Missing: git resolution, transitive deps, registry, `tree/update/vendor`, `--offline`, environment materialization. |
| **P4** Security core and isolation | **Partial** | `CapabilityHost`, capabilities at execution points (console and math included), project-rooted FS with traversal rejection, budgets, effect trace, pure/project modes, **strict refuses without OS isolation** (`marqdo-sandbox`); CLI test `strict_mode_refuses_without_isolation`; host unit tests. Missing: OS isolation adapter, plugin worker, network enforcement. |
| **P5** Math and Foreign | **Partial (documented subset)** | `marqdo-math` exact-rational formula kernel for the grammar in `spec/math.md`; `math.parse/eval/substitute` host ops; `marqdo-foreign` Python/Node one-shot kernels with typed `foreign.call`; tests `crates/marqdo-math/tests/kernel.rs`, `crates/marqdo-foreign/tests/kernels.rs`; examples `math.mq.md`, `python-foreign.mq.md`. Missing: `simplify`/`differentiate`, matrices/series/symbolic algebra, foreign sessions, Python environment management. |
| **P6** Plugin ABI and developer experience | **Partial** | Frozen `include/marqdo_plugin_abi_v1.h`; C ABI mirrors/layout assertions, version negotiation, `plugin.yaml` validation, target triple + sha256 verification, wire envelopes, native loader (`marqdo-plugin-abi`); Rust SDK macro (`marqdo-plugin-sdk`); C demo (`examples/plugin-demo`); CLI `plugin inspect` and explicitly trusted in-process invocation (`--plugin`, `--trust-native-plugin`, `--allow-plugin`); tests `plugin_inspect_and_explicit_trusted_invocation`, `crates/marqdo-plugin-abi/tests/loader_unix.rs`. Missing: isolated worker transport, plugin capability bridge, installation, Rust plugin example crate. |
| **P7** Performance, release, CI | **Partial** | `.github/workflows/ci.yml` runs fmt/clippy/workspace tests plus CLI example smoke tests (including plugin inspect and invocation) on Linux x86_64. Missing: benchmarks, bytecode backend, cross-platform matrix, signed releases and supply-chain checks. Tree-walk interpreter only. |
## 2. Feature evidence (selected commands)
| Command | Verified behavior |
|---|---|
| `marqdo init demo` | creates `marqdo.yaml` (`>=0.1,<1`), `index.mq.md`, `.gitignore` (`.marqdo/`); refuses existing manifest (exit 1). |
| `marqdo check index.mq.md` | static only; 0 when no error diagnostics (warnings allowed); 1 on errors; JSON `command/success/errors/diagnostics`. |
| `marqdo run index.mq.md` | executes `main` through the Rust interpreter/host; program stdout on stdout; exit 1 on runtime/compile/strict errors. |
| `marqdo call file fn --arg n=5` | typed constant arguments; prints the non-`Unit` return value. |
| `marqdo inspect file --ast/--units/--signature/--ir/--refs/--platform --json` | static dashboards; `--platform` reports strict unavailable. |
| `marqdo fmt [--check]` | normalizes CRLF and trailing newlines only; exit 1 if `--check` detects a change. |
| `marqdo plugin inspect dir` | validates manifest + verifies sha256; never `dlopen`s (`loaded: false`). |
| `marqdo run doc --plugin dir --trust-native-plugin --allow-plugin demo.solver` | calls `solver.add(a=20,b=22)` and prints `42`; without trust/grant it exits 1. |
| `marqdo lock` / `sync --locked` | deterministic path-dependency lock; `--locked` fails on manifest/dependency drift. |
Test corpus at this snapshot (`tests/README.md`):
* 150 AST fixtures + goldens (`tests/conformance/ast/`);
* 36 semantic execution fixtures + goldens (`tests/conformance/semantics/`);
* 48 compile-time hard-error fixtures, 6 inert-executable warning fixtures,
10 runtime-error fixtures (`tests/negative/`);
* `crates/cli/tests/` harnesses: `conformance_ast`, `conformance_semantics`,
`negative`, `properties`, `integration_cli`;
* crate tests across all 15 crates, including real `python3`/`node` foreign
tests (skipped if unavailable) and a compiled C plugin test (skipped without
`cc`).
At this snapshot `cargo test -p marqdo-cli` passes all 21 harness tests
(2 CLI unit + AST/semantics/negative/properties/integration) and
`cargo test --workspace` passes. The fixture counts above match
`tests/README.md`; empty `tests/integration`, `tests/properties`,
`tests/security` and `tests/abi` directories are reserved for future
workstreams — the active corpus lives in `tests/conformance`, `tests/negative`
and `crates/cli/tests`.
## 3. Open items by phase
### P0
* Wire floats now round-trip exactly: `serde_json`'s `float_roundtrip`
feature is enabled and a Python `math.pi * 9` fixture pins the exact value
(`spec/value-wire.md` §3).
* Profile change safety relies on the frozen-options unit test; no CI gate
regenerates goldens (intentional).
### P1
* The blueprint asks for a draft Turing-completeness argument. The language
supports mutable locals, branch-first-match, per-item `while` loops and
recursion with bounded budgets; a formal encoding write-up is still missing.
* The default cooperative stack budget is 128 frames so very deep recursion
yields a structured `resource.exhausted` instead of exhausting the debug-build
native stack; `--stack` raises it deliberately. A true guard-page/iterative
interpreter hardening is still open.
### P2
* `fmt` is intentionally minimal (line endings/trailing newlines only), not the
blueprint's "canonical AST-equivalent formatting"; no semantic formatting,
AST-equivalence check or render-preserving rewrite exists.
* Reference validation is opt-in: `check --refs` (and `inspect --refs`) resolve
links; plain `check` does not fail on broken links because links are static
knowledge references rather than execution inputs.
* Link-form calls cannot cross modules; cross-module calls use imported alias
expressions. The blueprint's `> [f](./other.mq.md#f)(...)` example is not
supported.
* `ref("#...")` is module-local and does not accept a selector for units with
multiple resources (it errors with `ref.ambiguous`, ADR-0003).
* No rename tooling, interface lock/ABI diffing, or incremental cache.
* Duplicate/nested project boundaries are not diagnosed (nearest
`marqdo.yaml` wins).
### P3
* Git dependencies can be declared (`git` + `rev`, validated) but cannot be
resolved or locked: `lock` errors "git dependencies are not supported by this
build".
* No transitive dependency graph, conflict resolution, registry, publishing,
signing, `tree`, `update`, `vendor`, `--offline`, or `lock --locked`.
* No environment materialization (`.marqdo/env`, caches, kernels, sessions);
`sync` verifies but never installs or rewrites.
* `add`/`remove` are shallow manifest editors; adding a git dependency succeeds
at the manifest level even though `lock` will later refuse it.
* JSON errors from `add`/`remove`/`lock`/`sync` are plain stderr even with
`--json`.
### P4
* **Strict mode cannot run at all**: no OS isolation adapter (Linux
namespaces/seccomp/cgroups, Windows Job Object/appcontainer, macOS sandbox)
and `worker_processes: false`; `run --mode strict` exits 1 (ADR-0004).
* `console` capability is always on; `print` is not capability-checked.
* Network capability (`net_hosts`, `check_net`) exists but no host operation
performs network I/O and there is no `--allow-net` flag.
* Write-path symlink TOCTOU caveat (`spec/security.md` §2.1); symlink/race
hardening open.
* Budgets do not cover every allocation path; the interpreter's containers are
bounded only by fuel and available memory.
* Effect trace does not record argument values or paths (privacy-positive, but
less diagnostic detail); trace is opt-in and implicitly on for `--json`.
* `plugin_handle` wire values are structurally reconstructable, not
unforgeable capability tokens.
### P5
* Math is a deliberately limited calculator subset: no `simplify`,
`differentiate`, matrices, sums/integrals, trig/log functions, units,
assumptions or theorem proving. `math.simplify`/`math.differentiate` are
host ops that always return `math.unsupported`.
* Equation solving is affine-only, single target, target must occur exactly
once; other shapes are `math.unsupported`.
* Division by zero inside a formula maps to `runtime.type` (via
`MathErrorKind::Type`), not `runtime.division_by_zero`; documented divergence.
* Foreign kernels are one-shot only: no sessions, state bridge, Python/Node
environment management, or network policy for child processes.
* Foreign child processes are terminated only when the direct child is killed;
grandchildren are not tracked.
* Foreign per-call timeout (10 s) and output cap (1 MiB) are not CLI-configurable.
### P6
* No isolated plugin worker (length-prefixed IPC) or Wasm transport; only
explicitly trusted in-process native loading. A native plugin crash is a host
crash (`spec/plugin-abi.md` §1/§9).
* No plugin capability bridge from the CLI: plugins are loaded with no
capability handler, so every plugin `request_capability` is denied.
* Plugin calls are not statically validated; unknown namespaces are runtime
`symbol.unknown`. Positional plugin arguments are rejected.
* One namespace per plugin (first export prefix); multi-prefix manifests are not
reachable beyond the first prefix.
* No plugin installation/package management; `plugins:` in `marqdo.yaml` is
declarative only. No Rust plugin example crate (SDK has doc examples/tests).
* No hot unload/reload (ABI v1 design).
### P7
* Performance work is untouched: no benchmark suite, no bytecode backend or
differential tests against the tree-walker, no parse/compile caching.
* No CI workflows (`.github/` is empty of workflow files); no
Windows/macOS/Linux matrix, sanitizers/fuzz gates, signing, release
automation or supply-chain scanning.
* No published version, no compatibility matrix beyond the frozen ABI/format
documents.
## 4. Blueprint §18 "Alpha Definition of Done" mapping
| §18 item | Status | Evidence / gap |
|---|---|---|
| Run/call non-trivial recursive, branch, loop, call, parameter-inference programs without Python | **Met** | factorial/recursion (`examples/factorial.mq.md`, runtime + semantic goldens), countdown loop, multi-module alias call; interpreter is native Rust. |
| `.mq.md` readable under the chosen CommonMark/GFM/Math profile; standard AST behavior covered by goldens | **Met** | frozen `marqdo.md.v1`, 150 AST goldens, profile option test, `spec/markdown-profile.md`. |
| No heuristic downgrade of execution semantics; accurate source locations for invalid execution nodes | **Mostly met** | hard errors with spans for function-body executable shapes and negative corpus. Gaps: inert executable outside functions is a warning by design (ADR-0002); cross-module runtime error spans resolve against the entry file only; some lazy nested nodes are inert without a warning. |
| `check`/`inspect` side-effect free; imports, calls and static references verifiable across files | **Mostly met** | static load/analysis only; imports + cycle detection; cross-module calls validated; `check --refs` validates references across loaded documents and statically analyses link targets; `inspect --refs` prints the entry graph. |
| Minimal manifest, lock file, path/Git dependencies and environment sync | **Partial** | manifest/lock/path works, `sync --locked` verifies; git resolution, transitive deps, environment materialization and `--offline` missing. |
| All host side effects capability-authorized; untrusted code/native plugins cannot masquerade as strict sandbox | **Mostly met** | capability checks at execution points; strict refuses; native plugins require explicit trust and are documented as unsandboxed. Gaps: network enforcement not implemented (no network builtin is exposed), no worker isolation. |
| Formula computational subset explicit/testable; Foreign I/O, timeout and permissions explicit | **Met for the documented subset** | `spec/math.md`, `spec/foreign.md`; math kernel tests; foreign tests (timeout, protocol, output cap, env); permission gating tests/smoke. Simplification/differentiation explicitly unsupported. |
| Plugin C ABI v1, Rust SDK, C example, isolated worker basic path, ABI compat error tests | **Partial** | ABI/SDK/C example/loader/ABI-error tests exist; **isolated worker path missing**. |
| CI has at least one full research pipeline: Markdown function → Math → Foreign → Plugin → controlled output | **Partial** | CI now runs fmt/clippy/tests and CLI smoke tests; individual math/foreign/plugin paths are covered by examples and tests, but no single end-to-end pipeline document/test exists yet. |
| Examples, README, AGENTS and contributor docs allow a first change without legacy context | **Met** | `README.md`, `AGENTS.md`, this guide, `docs/STATUS.md`, specs, ADRs, `tests/README.md`, examples. |
**Conclusion: the Alpha definition of done is not fully met.** P0/P1 and the
documented P5 subset are solid; P2/P3/P4/P6 are functional but partial; P7 is
absent. The blocking items for an Alpha claim are the strict sandbox/worker
isolation story (P4/P6), git/environment package management (P3), and a CI
end-to-end pipeline (P7).
## 5. What is deliberately limited (do not overclaim)
* Only a single, frozen Markdown profile (`marqdo.md.v1`); changing parser
options/versions is a language change.
* Strict mode is a refusal, not an isolation implementation. `project` mode is
cooperative and in-process.
* Native plugins are trusted in-process code; there is no isolated plugin
worker, and a plugin crash takes down the host.
* Ints are arbitrary precision; finite floats are binary64 and wire round-trip
is exact (`float_roundtrip` enabled), but decimal-vs-binary formatting still
applies when displaying values.
* Math is a limited exact-rational calculator, not a CAS or a prover.
* Foreign kernels are optional, one-shot, unsandboxed child processes.
* `fmt` is minimal; `check` does not yet validate Markdown links; link-form
calls cannot cross modules.
* Package management is path-only in practice; `marqdo.yaml` capabilities are
requests, never grants.