Files
marqdo-cli/COMPATIBILITY.md
T
cflmy 0b01cbd2a4 evidence(ext): SHA-bound frozen-CLI external conformance manifest; finalize RFC-EXT-0001 record
- docs/evidence/extension/6a7bb98.../manifest.json: tested_sha 6a7bb98,
  cli sha256 28e3776d..., fixture repo e4b7352c..., all 7 required categories PASS
- RFC-EXT-0001 status Implemented with PR-by-PR record and honest release caveat
- STATUS/CURRENT/COMPATIBILITY/evidence report bind the executed result
- workspace gate re-run: fmt/clippy clean, 599 passed across 67 targets

Code tree at 6a7bb98 is byte-identical; this commit adds evidence/docs only.
2026-11-22 00:48:39 +08:00

162 lines
11 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# Compatibility and support matrix
Snapshot: workspace version **0.1.0**, RFC-EXT-0001 tree on
`feat/extensible-ecosystem`, no release tag cut. This file records what was
actually verified and separates it from what is only implemented. Executed
status is in [`docs/STATUS.md`](docs/STATUS.md); SHA-bound external evidence is
under [`docs/evidence/extension/`](docs/evidence/extension/README.md).
## Language source syntax (breaking change)
**The `.mq.md` source language is a breaking change.** The current contract is
[RFC-LANG-0002](docs/architecture/RFC-LANG-0002-unified-semantics.md)
(accepted by [ADR-0052](docs/adr/0052-unified-markdown-semantics.md)), with the
normative summaries in [`spec/mapping.md`](spec/mapping.md) and
[`spec/expression.ebnf`](spec/expression.ebnf):
- H1–H6 headings declare `@exec`/`@knowledge` modes; unmarked headings inherit
the nearest ancestor's mode and the document root is Knowledge.
- Only an Exec H2 is a callable function. H2 Knowledge is inert and H3–H6 are
non-callable sections.
- In an Exec scope, `Strong`, `Emph` and inline `Code` are interchangeable
carriers of one statement; the original emphasis role is gone.
- Control flow comes from keywords in the payload (`if`/`else`/`while`/`end`/
`return`/`params(...)`). Ordered lists, bullet lists and block quotes are
inert presentation containers.
- There is no version selector, `--legacy` path or fallback mapper.
Consequences for compatibility:
- **Old pre-RFC `.mq.md` source is not executable.** A file that relied on
`Strong` = execute, `Emph` = return, ordered list = branch, bullet list =
loop, block quote = call or a first code-span signature must be rewritten by
AST role (see `docs/migration/README.md`). A parse failure is a hard
diagnostic, never a fallback to prose.
- The Markdown parser profile stays `marqdo.md.v1`; only the Markdown→program
mapping changed. Rendering of otherwise-ordinary Markdown is unaffected.
- **Implementation state:** RFC-LANG-0002 is implemented by the frontend,
expression parser, IR lowering, runtime and bundled stdlib. At
`9c1723d` the workspace gate is
`cargo test --workspace --locked`: 507 passed, 0 failed, 2 ignored, and the
stdlib digest is regenerated and verified. See
[`docs/STATUS.md`](docs/STATUS.md) and
[`docs/evidence/2026-11-21-semantics-v2-green.md`](docs/evidence/2026-11-21-semantics-v2-green.md).
## Public protocol versions
| Surface | Version | Compatibility rule |
|---|---|---|
| Markdown profile | `marqdo.md.v1` | Frozen parser/options. The RFC-LANG-0002 mapping rewrite keeps this profile; the source-language break is tracked above, not by a new profile id. |
| Language / CLI | workspace `0.1.0` | Pre-1.0. The `.mq.md` source language changed incompatibly (RFC-LANG-0002); there is no old-syntax execution path. CLI flags may change with a changelog note; `strict` refusal is contractual. |
| `marqdo.lock` | v4 | v3 is rejected with an explicit `marqdo lock` migration error; v1/v2 are rejected with a relock instruction; `run`/`call`/`check` never rewrite or fetch the lock. `extensions:` records manifest/artifact identity (integrity, not publisher auth). |
| Analysis | v2 | Consumers reject unknown majors; incompatible field changes require v3. |
| Trace | v2 | Binds to the exact Analysis bytes; unknown majors rejected. |
| CLI Tool | v1 | Manifest schema, SemVer negotiation and whole-bundle digest are stable for v1. |
| Plugin ABI | v1 | Struct layout/version negotiation frozen; `--trust-native-plugin` is required for in-process loading. The static manifest signature is authoritative; `run` reconciles loaded exports/signatures/owners/artifact digests exactly (`ext.plugin_binding_mismatch`); ABI v1 defaults are rejected. |
| Resource Provider manifest | v2 | `schema_version: 2`, `abi: c-abi-1`, `transport: worker`; v1 is rejected (`ext.unsupported_provider_schema`), no silent migration. CLI `--provider`/`--allow-provider`; trusted worker, not an OS sandbox. |
| Callable resolution | ADR-0054 | One registry + one binding pass; `check` and `run` bind the same `CallSiteKey`; no runtime name fallback. Import aliases colliding with builtin/plugin dotted namespaces are rejected. |
| Analysis `calls[].state/target` | v2 (projection) | Now projected from the unique binding; official stdlib aliases appear as `function`. Schema/version unchanged; private binding table not serialized. |
| Extension selection | lock v4 | `marqdo.yaml.extensions` only `./path` or `@alias/path`; declaration is not a grant; declared identity must match the lock (`ext.extension_lock_mismatch`). |
| Foreign wire | v1 | One-shot request envelope; provider descriptors are explicit. |
## Platform / feature evidence
Legend: **PASS** = executed on this snapshot with logs; **UNVERIFIED** = code is
portable/tested locally but the native platform lane has not run here;
**UNSUPPORTED** = deliberately not claimed; **FAIL-CLOSED** = request is refused.
| Feature | Ubuntu Linux x86_64 | macOS arm64 | Windows x86_64 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Markdown profile / AST goldens (160) | PASS | UNVERIFIED (cfg fix + CRLF fix) | UNVERIFIED (cfg fix + CRLF fix) |
| Rust interpreter / unified semantics (73) | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Addressable `Memory` P1 (ADR-0022) | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Resource streams CM-A06 (ADR-0025/0026: stdout + project file read/write) | PASS | UNVERIFIED | **FAIL-CLOSED** (`strict` refuses resource opens) |
| `run` / `call` / `check` / `inspect` / `fmt` | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| lock v4 path/Git graph + sync + tamper | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Extension selection/lock v4 (`extensions:`, identities, `inspect --extensions`) | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Callable single binding + `ext.import_namespace_conflict`/`symbol.unknown`/plugin reconciliation | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Official stdlib public aliases (print de-magic; byte-identical output) | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Resource Provider v2 CLI (`--provider`/`--allow-provider`, worker helper) | PASS (linux/x86_64; real C sensor + helper) | **FAIL-CLOSED** (`ext.platform_unsupported`) | **UNSUPPORTED** |
| Capability handler registry (`fs.read` handler, audit, unavailable) | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| External conformance repository (`marqdo-extension-conformance`, frozen CLI) | PASS (`--release` binary sha256 `28e3776d…`, fixture repo `e4b7352c…`; see `docs/evidence/extension/6a7bb983.../manifest.json`) | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Analysis v2 / Trace v2 + Python consumers | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Tool Protocol v1 + 3 independent consumers | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Native ABI (`plugin inspect`, trusted call) | PASS (C fixture) | UNVERIFIED (host-native fixture) | **UNSUPPORTED** |
| Worker ABI + `fs.read` bridge | PASS (Unix) | UNVERIFIED | **UNSUPPORTED** (Unix-gated) |
| Foreign Python/Node | PASS (system `python3`/`node`) | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| Foreign pinned environment binding | PASS | UNVERIFIED | UNVERIFIED |
| `strict` Linux L1 (pure Marqdo + Math) | PASS, probe-gated, 7/7 VM lane | **FAIL-CLOSED** | **FAIL-CLOSED** |
| `strict` L2 (Worker/Foreign/native) | **UNSUPPORTED** (flags refused) | **UNSUPPORTED** | **UNSUPPORTED** |
The Ubuntu column is from this development host (Ubuntu 26.04 container) and a
disposable Ubuntu 26.04 QEMU/TCG VM for the security lane. It is **not** a
GitHub Actions result: this checkout has a Gitee remote and no GitHub
credentials. A fresh local clone with `core.autocrlf=true` was used to
reproduce the Windows checkout byte behavior.
## Strict L1 scope (ADR-0021)
- Enabled only when the runtime Bubblewrap probe succeeds. Probe failure or a
probe→launch race exits non-zero with a diagnostic and **never** falls back
to `project`.
- Inside the sandbox: user/mount/PID/net/UTS/IPC namespaces, no-new-privs,
empty capabilities, read-only `/project`, private `/proc`/`/dev`/`/tmp`,
rlimits and wall-clock/output supervision; the child verifies `PID 1`,
`NoNewPrivs`, `CapEff=0`, a non-initial uid map and no non-loopback network.
- Refused before launch: `--allow-read`, `--allow-write`, `--allow-foreign`,
`--allow-plugin`, `--plugin`, `--trust-native-plugin`, `--kernel`,
`--trace-file`.
- Strict L2 (letting Worker/Foreign/native plugin run inside the sandbox) is
not implemented and must not be inferred from L1 passing.
## Minimum environment
- Rust 1.82+ (verified with 1.100.0).
- Linux/macOS: a C compiler for Native ABI fixtures; Python/Node only for
Foreign kernels; `git` for Git dependencies.
- `strict` additionally requires Bubblewrap and a kernel/environment that
permits user, mount, PID and network namespaces. See
[`docs/security-gate.md`](docs/security-gate.md) and ADR-0021.
## RFC-EXT-0001 platform statements
* Provider worker transport: linux/x86_64 only; macOS/Windows return
`ext.platform_unsupported` (compile-only, fail-closed). The RFC's macOS
provider lane is **not claimed**.
* Windows Native/Worker ABI remains **UNSUPPORTED**; a Linux PASS does not
substitute for it.
* `strict` L1 continues to refuse plugins/providers/foreign kernels; strict L2
is not implemented. A worker is a trusted process, not an OS sandbox.
* The external conformance suite is a mandatory **additional** release gate
(`docs/releasing.md` §7); it does not replace G3/G4/native lanes.
## Explicitly unsupported in this candidate
- Pre-RFC `.mq.md` source syntax (Strong-execute / Emph-return / ordered-list
branch / bullet-list loop / block-quote call / first code-span signature).
Old sources are a rewrite task, not a compatibility mode: there is no
`--legacy`, `marqdo_semantics` selector or second mapper.
- OS-level strict isolation on macOS/Windows (Linux only, probe-gated).
- Strict L2: Worker/Foreign execution inside strict (refused in L1).
- Windows Native/Worker ABI runtime support.
- Automatic uv/npm/venv provisioning; only an explicitly provisioned, pinned
directory is verified (and must contain a regular-file executable).
- Registry/package publishing, JIT, Knowledge/Proof/View built-ins,
sessions, and general-purpose CAS. The three `sample-*` tools are test
fixtures for the generic Tool protocol, not product features.
- Tagged Windows/macOS release archives: the native **build/test** matrix is
green at `5fcc111`, but the tag/dispatch release-candidate job has not
produced those archives.
## Release decision
**DO NOT RELEASE.** The RFC-CI-0001 series fixed the platform `E0425` build
break, the strict `--json` empty-stdout defect (ADR-0053) and the native
Windows/macOS portability failures. Linux, Windows and macOS native jobs are
green, and G4 is `MEASURED`/`WARN` on the designated Woodpecker agent
(`1199c88`, 9/9 correctness-verified, pinned CPU). The release still lacks the
**remote G3 security artifact** with a matching `tested_sha`; a local VM PASS
is not a remote G3 proof. The G4 node is a shared powersave host, so its gate
is provisional. See [`docs/STATUS.md`](docs/STATUS.md) §0.1 and
[`docs/evidence/ci/README.md`](docs/evidence/ci/README.md).